‍Microsoft Shuts Xandr, Netflix and YouTube Double Down on AI Ads: What It Means for Advertisers

Listen here:

TL:DR;

Microsoft shutting down Xandr signals a major shift toward AI-powered advertising. Instead of open programmatic buying, Microsoft is focusing on its in-house tools like Copilot, which uses AI to plan and manage ad campaigns. For advertisers, this means fewer third-party buying options and more reliance on platform-owned AI systems.

As adtech giants consolidate and generative AI reshapes the ad landscape, one thing still drives results: great creative.

Table of Contents

1. Why Microsoft Closed Xandr
   
2. Netflix and YouTube’s AI-Powered Ad Strategy
   
3. The Real Shift: From Open Web to Walled Gardens
   
4. The Rise of AI in Advertising: Helpful or Harmful?
   
5. Why Creative Still Matters More Than Ever
   
6. How Creative Analytics Gives You Back Control
   
7. How Advertisers Can Adapt to AI-Driven Platforms
   
8. Key Takeaway: Creative Is Your Competitive Edge
   

Why Microsoft Closed Xandr

In a surprise move, Microsoft announced it’s shutting down Xandr, its demand-side platform (DSP). Instead of selling it, Microsoft is going all-in on AI-led media planning and buying.

Tools like Microsoft Copilot now allow marketers to manage campaigns via a chat interface, suggesting placements, budgets, and even creative direction, all powered by AI.

This signals a broader shift across the industry: traditional programmatic buying is being replaced by platform-owned AI ecosystems. And Microsoft isn’t alone.

Netflix and YouTube’s AI-Powered Ad Strategy

Both Netflix and YouTube are leaning into AI, but not just behind the scenes.

At its 2025 Upfronts, Netflix introduced generative AI ad formats that appear inside content. Think:

• Branded products integrated into scenes
  
• Pause-screen interactivity
  
• Personalized placements based on your behavior
  

Meanwhile, YouTube is rolling out AI-powered “Peak Points” ads, designed to place brands at emotionally resonant moments in videos. It also continues to expand AI tools that auto-resize and optimize creative.

The result? Platforms are tightening control, and advertisers must adapt to their formats, rules, and algorithms.

From Open Web to Walled Gardens

These changes reflect a larger trend: the collapse of the open web in favor of closed ecosystems.

• Media buying paths are narrowing
  
• Access to inventory is gated
  
• Data, formats, and performance feedback are increasingly controlled by the platforms
  

If you’re running ads, you’re now playing by Netflix, YouTube, or Microsoft’s rules. You’ll need to work within the constraints of their creative systems, targeting models, and optimization algorithms.

The Rise of AI in Advertising

In theory, this level of automation would lead to:

• Right user
  
• Right time
  
• Right message
  

But when everything is decided for you, advertisers risk losing visibility. You might no longer know:

• Who your best audience actually is
  
• Why one creative performs better than another
  
• What signals really matter
  

Without insight, optimization becomes guesswork.

Why Creative Still Matters

Even in an AI-first world, one thing hasn’t changed: creative is still the #1 driver of performance.

According to Nielsen, creative accounts for nearly 50% of ad sales impact. Your copy, visuals, and tone still carry more weight than bidding strategies or audience segments.

In fact, the more uniform media buying becomes, the more your creative becomes the last real differentiator.

How Creative Analytics Helps You Stay in Control

You can’t fight the rise of AI, but you can feed it better inputs.

That’s where creative analytics comes in.

Tools like AdSkate analyze your ad creatives, images, objects, color tones, copy, and calls-to-action, and correlate them with performance metrics. This helps you:

• Understand what’s actually working
  
• Improve future ad iterations
  
• Stay independent from platform bias
  

It’s your way of regaining control in a world increasingly run by algorithms.

How Advertisers Can Adapt

Here’s how smart marketers are navigating the shift:

• Diversify your creatives. Launch campaigns with 5–7 versions to improve testing and performance.
  
• Use AI for efficiency, not originality. Let AI reformat and resize, but keep the ideas human.
  
• Track creative-specific performance. Don’t just look at CTRs and ROAS, dig into which visuals, tones, or messages drive results.
  
• Pre-test campaigns. Use pre-campaign analysis tools to predict which creative will resonate before you spend big.
  
• Stay human. Even in a fully automated landscape, human stories and ideas are what make people stop and care.
  

Creative Is Your Edge

Platforms will change, AI will evolve, and rules will tighten.

But your creative, how you tell your brand’s story, visually and emotionally, is still yours.

In a landscape of sameness, that’s where you stand out.